Navigation
[deleted]
[deleted] - Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Was this draconian lockdown necessary
More than 100 posts
Posted: 2020-04-24 11:12:05

While the majority of us are lockdown and without an income. Not to mentioned the millions who are unemployed and starving. Is this lockdown realistic.

www.businesslive.co.za/fm/features/2020-04-24-sas-covid-19-models-were-flawed-says-former-nicd-expert/
Mr3
Mr3 - Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Basic Member
Joined:
25 Apr 2019
Posts to Date: 119
View Profile
Posted: 2020-04-24 11:19:08

This lockdown was just to give government time to:
1. Get their house a bit in order
2. Build some ventilators
3. Work on a plan how they are going to remove the corpses (why else do you think the Armybwas increased to 75000)
4. Decide location of mass graves...
john_adams
john_adams - Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Basic Member
Joined:
10 Apr 2010
Posts to Date: 348
View Profile
Posted: 2020-04-24 11:31:07

Mr3 i think you should look at the stats especially in Sweden where the government took very little action and you will see that the death rate is actually very low , most people dying here in the next few months will be of starvation
Mr3
Mr3 - Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Basic Member
Joined:
25 Apr 2019
Posts to Date: 121
View Profile
Posted: 2020-04-24 11:51:56

On 2020-04-24 11:31:07 john_adams said:
Mr3 i think you should look at the stats especially in Sweden where the government took very little action and you will see that the death rate is actually very low , most people dying here in the next few months will be of starvation



Not going to go into a debate, but a massive amount of HIv, TB and other related diseases have significant high comorbidity with Covid19. Fact of the matter is, all is going to gwt it, either this year or next year.
[deleted]
[deleted] - Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Less than 5 posts
Posted: 2020-04-24 12:05:01

On 2020-04-24 11:51:56 Mr3 said:
On 2020-04-24 11:31:07 john_adams said: Mr3 i think you should look at the stats especially in Sweden where the government took very little action and you will see that the death rate is actually very low , most people dying here in the next few months will be of starvation

Not going to go into a debate, but a massive amount of HIv, TB and other related diseases have significant high comorbidity with Covid19. Fact of the matter is, all is going to gwt it, either this year or next year.



Actually the research is pointing to the fact that patients on ARVs, as well as anyone born in SA post 1973 (as they all received the BCG vaccine against TB) are significantly more protected against SARS-Cov-19. Current projections estimate around 40% of the population will get the disease within the space of 5 years (provided no cure and/or vaccine is found) and of those 40% less then 80 000 over 5 years ultimately die. Less then seasonal flu.
Louise ( Miss Red)
Louise ( Miss Red) - Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Advertiser
Joined:
17 May 2018
Posts to Date: 2506
  View Profile  
Posted: 2020-04-24 12:21:40

On 2020-04-24 11:31:07 john_adams said:
Mr3 i think you should look at the stats especially in Sweden where the government took very little action and you will see that the death rate is actually very low , most people dying here in the next few months will be of starvation




Sweden should not be a model to follow for S.A.. As Sweden has excellent health care systems compared to S.A... . Just saying...
UnlikelySuspect
UnlikelySuspect - Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Basic Member
Joined:
23 Mar 2012
Posts to Date: 665
View Profile
Posted: 2020-04-24 12:29:25

Can't compare any country to another. Too many variables.
Vrik
Vrik - Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Gold Member
Joined:
10 Feb 2019
Posts to Date: 596
View Profile
Posted: 2020-04-24 12:40:47

On 2020-04-24 11:19:08 Mr3 said:
This lockdown was just to give government time to:
1. Get their house a bit in order
2. Build some ventilators
3. Work on a plan how they are going to remove the corpses (why else do you think the Armybwas increased to 75000)
4. Decide location of mass graves...



True. But it was not necessary to extend the original 3 weeks. They should have gotten their ducks in a row during the first 3 weeks.
[deleted]
[deleted] - Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
More than 100 posts
Posted: 2020-04-24 13:35:26

Ducks in a row? In SA? Only time the ducks will form a row is when something is handed out for free.
gooseberry22
gooseberry22 - Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Re: Was this draconian lockdown necessary
Basic Member
Joined:
22 Apr 2012
Posts to Date: 251
View Profile
Posted: 2020-04-24 15:07:40

Someone will be able to answer this thread title with a reasonable degree of accuracy based on facts.

In about a year from now.

Reply

You must be logged in to post on this forum. Basic Membership is free and it only takes a minute to sign up. Alternatively, if you are already a member, please log in. You will be automatically returned to this page.

Legend


Hover mouse over icons for description

Back to Previous Page
For the best browsing experience, rotate your tablet horizontal.